Vicars of St Nicholas Church, Old Marston
| c.1210 | Osbert son of Hereward (Heward) |
| pre-1263 | Walter |
| 1263 | Richard |
| 1264 | Kytellus (Ketellus) |
| 1273 | William de Mercham |
| pre-1297 | Adam de Wolford |
| 1297 | Stephen de Lynermene (Chaplain) |
| 1304 | Henry Brid (de Langgebergh) |
| 1320 | Roger de Undele |
| 1324 | Richard de Grafton |
| 1330 | Henry de Keten (Ketone) |
| 1349 | John de Bradeley (died of Black Death) |
| 1349 | Hugh de Wappenham |
| 1361 | William de Hedyngdon |
| pre-1382 | Thomas Silveston |
| 1382 | Richard de Morton |
| 1397 | Robert Kene (Kent) |
| 1398 | Adam Wyllyam |
| 1407 | Hugh de la Ryner |
| 1407 | Thomas Thornbury (Canon of St Frideswide’s) |
| 1423 | Theobald Wynchester (Canon of St Frideswide’s) |
| 1424 | John Henton |
In 1451 the benefices of Marston and Headington were united by a papal bull
|
|
| pre-1460 | Lewis ...... |
| 1460 | M. William Barfoot |
| 1483 | M. Richard Chauncellor |
| 1484 | M. Thomas Gilbert |
| 1486 | John London (Canon of St Frideswide’s) |
| 1529 | Thomas Fylldar (Dominican) |
In 1637 Marston became a separate parish again on the representation of the Crown
|
|
| 1637 | John Allen |
| 1685 | Francis Shaw |
| 1686 | Robert Holloway |
| 1689 | John Duke |
| 1690 | William Smith |
| 1705 | Robert Railton (Raylton) |
| 1717 | Joseph Stockwell |
| 1728 | Carew Reynell |
| 1734 | William Thomas |
| 1738 | Thomas Berdmore |
| 1742 | William Burrough |
| 1752 | William Wright |
| 1758 | John Coxe |
| 1771 | Henry Macock |
| 1804 | Thomas Harward |
| 1805 | Thomas Henry Whorwood* (also Vicar of Headington) |
| 1835 | James Peterson Chambers |
| 1836 | Thomas Henry Whorwood* |
| 1849 | Richard Gordon (also Vicar of Elsfield) |
| 1872 | John Philip Smith |
| 1888 | Charles Morris |
| 1899 | Harvey Altham Cumberlege |
| 1904 | John Hamilton Mortimer |
| 1952 | Gordon David Savage |
| 1957 | Leslie Vandernoll Wright |
| 1959 | Paul Nathanael Rimmer |
| 1991 | Anthony Ronald Price |
* These Vicars (father and son) were Lords of the Manor of Headington. Thomas Henry Whorwood senior (who had appointed himself Vicar of Headington in 1804) also appointed himself Vicar of Marston in 1806, the year he succeeded his father as Lord and came to live in the Manor House in Osler Road. He held both posts until his death in 1835. He had originally intended that his eldest son of the same name should succeed him as Vicar of Headington and his younger son, William Henry, as Vicar of Marston; but the latter disgraced himself, and so Marston got the elder son instead (until he was appointed Vicar of Willoughby in Warwickshire in 1849).